?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

100 TV shows #81-M*A*S*H

M*A*S*H



One fic only-written for Yuletide: Lots of angst. Goodbye Means Goodbye

A MEME answer to "Saddest Character Death Ever!"

Still determined to finish this thing.

One of the specific quotes I remember from One Day At a Time, was from an episode where the older daughter was trying to get her mom to pay for a private school and was trying to make the case that she would get a better education than in the public school she was going to. One of her arguments was, “If it weren’t for M*A*S*H, I would never have heard of the Korean War.”



Of course we all know that M*A*S*H wasn’t really about the Korean war, but in 1972, I didn’t know that. I hadn’t read the book or seen the movie, which was way too grown up for me. In retrospect, the show was pretty “grown-up” as well, and a lot of it went over my head…although I was a pretty savvy kid, so I might have gotten a lot of the historical references ahead of learning any of it in school. It was one of my parent’s shows, probably my mom.

It’s definitely one of my earliest examples of me hating changes in a show, although I didn’t come close to the level of breath holding and bitching I would later perfect. As young as I would have been, MY M*A*S*H was definitely the original cast, especially Wayne Rogers (RIP) as Trapper. He’s the only one of the cast that I can remember having a crush on, which carried through to City of Angels. When Mr. Rogers passed on---at the end of the last year, before we knew how many great ones this year was planning to take from us---it definitely reminded me how much I loved Trapper (as played by Mr. Rogers…Sorry to say that when I did see the movie Elliot Gould didn’t do much for me.) I never warmed up to BJ as a replacement. Wayne Rogers was a major crush for young K-gal. The curls, the dimples and the fact that Trapper screwed everything and didn’t seem terribly emotionally involved. One of my earliest charming bastards.

Speaking of bastards...I also had a very hot thing for Colonel Flagg. However I think the character I personally related to and thought was the most decent of the lot was Sidney Freedman.

One of the few times I know I cried over a TV show was the announcement of Henry Blake’s death. I didn’t mind Colonel Potter, mostly because I liked Henry Gannon from Dragnet, but I still felt the dynamic of Hawkeye, Trapper, Henry, Klinger and Radar vs Hot Lips and Frank was best.

RE: Hot Lips and Frank…I reallyreallyreally hated what the show did to them as a couple and to their individual characters. I didn’t have the shipping concept at the time, but they were actually hot together and their dynamic of forbidden lust, even with all the hypocrisy involved, was one I would later glom onto. I get that in the initial concept they were the bad guys, because they were trying to get our heroes in trouble. (And presumably because they actually thought there was value in the war.)

I had not particular interest in Larry Linville…didn’t find him or the character attractive. I’m sure I hated him as much as the show told me I was supposed to, but they were the only couple on the show (aside from the slash ships that I was too young to fully be aware of and that of course were all subtext) that had overt passion for each other and that definitely came across to my younger self.

As the show progressed and I grew up, I feel it definitely screwed Frank over to make Hot Lips (excuse me, Margaret) look better. And I hated them for it. Really hated it. So much that I felt sorry for Frank when he was utterly destroyed. In my memory, they basically drove him crazy, had him committed and never gave any indication that he survived, got home, got his life back etc. I’m sure Wiki could tell me otherwise, but that’s what I was left with…and to keep it going and redeem Margaret, they had to make him so much worse. I know he was always supposed to not as good a doctor as Hawkeye et al, but they then went on to make him a very bad doctor and I resented that as well.

The more they tried to make me like Margaret and hate Frank, the more it had exactly the opposite effect. I’m even getting angry as I write this and I haven’t thought about it for a long time. These are some pretty dormant feels, but there they are.

Another change that pissed me off was the fact that Hawkeye was originally portrayed as being as big a pussyhound as Trapper, but that was diminished in the later seasons, presumably as Alan Alda took control of the show and wanted to be seen as the “nice guy.”

These are all impressions from my original watching of the show. I went through a brief re-watch period of the early first season when it was being shown on TV LAND years ago, mostly marveling at the original edge and the number of Hey, It’s That Guy types who showed up.

In spite of the aggro and the feels and the fact that I grew up enough to realize what was bugging me, I was still home and watching on February 28, 1983, when the finale aired, so I was part of what is still the largest viewing audience for a single television episode…at least in the days when you actually had to watch a TV show to watch a TV show.

I remember being annoyed by the plot, the manipulation, the pathos etc, but if I recall correctly I still cried at the end. Maybe more the for the “end of an era” feeling than the show itself. I never had any interest in Aftermash or Trapper John MD. (In spite of having a mega-crush on Pernell Roberts as Adam Cartwright.)

I’ll still get a little emotional when I hear the theme song, one of the most beautiful for any TV show ever, imported, of course, directly from the movie. Music written by Johnny Mandel and lyrics by Mike Altman, the son of the original film’s director, Robert Altman. Mike Altman, and was 15 years old when he wrote the song’s lyrics. Robert Altman once said that while he only made $70,000 for having directed the movie, his son had earned more than $1 million for having co-written the song.

Comments

( 9 comments — Leave a comment )
tourmaline1973
May. 3rd, 2016 08:02 pm (UTC)
I don't have a M*A*S*H userpic, so here's a Frasier one instead :)

Charles is still my favourite character, I think by the time they introduced him they had got any mistakes they made out of the way. I always thought Charles, Klinger and Father Mulcahy were the most believable characters. It felt like we never really got see any sustained depths to Trapper before Wayne Rogers left, not like with Henry Blake - there's a scene where he & Hawkeye are taking a break from a marathon OR session and he talks about how he appears to have a great medical practice back home, but it's routine work, and even though he hates being in Korea at least he can put his medical skills to better use. After seeing that scene that explained to me why he wasn't much of a leader, though he does honestly try, and he does so from the best intentions.
chocolate_frapp
May. 3rd, 2016 11:23 pm (UTC)
I had a giant crush on Alan Alda back in the 70s like I do on Hugh Laurie now, maybe I'm hardwired to like smartassy doctors. Frank was an effective bad guy but I also sort of felt sorry for him (although it was pretty hard to believe anyone that dumb was a doctor).
Nobody liked Aftermash. I saw it and was totally bored by it. There was another show with Radar that was even worse.
karaokegal
Jun. 20th, 2016 06:58 pm (UTC)
I hope you will share my amusement that yesterday in the Lounge, I had the opportunity to check in both a James Wilson and an Allison Cameron.
evila_elf
May. 6th, 2016 06:08 am (UTC)
MASH is what brought me to LJ. I used to hang around on ff.net and I had recently rediscovered the series. I was only 1 year old when the finale aired, and I first watched it when I was 10 or so, then again in my early to mid 20s. Found an amazing author and 'stalked her' a little, going to LJ to see when updates were. I never left.

I was part of a group of writers that all wrote fics for the show and we were all quite prolific. A handful of them I still bump into from time to time here. Then House happened and we all migrated to that fandom.

The MASH comms are all pretty dead now. Makes me sad :(
karaokegal
Jun. 19th, 2016 05:02 am (UTC)
Awwwww-sweet story.

Well I'm glad that MASH got you to LJ and then to House...because that's how we all met.

Are the fics still up?

evila_elf
Jun. 19th, 2016 10:51 am (UTC)
My fics, or the fics in the old community?
The old com was http://mash-slash.livejournal.com/
And my fics are in a sticky post at the top of my LJ
joanne_c
May. 7th, 2016 12:24 pm (UTC)
Your links go to the same place.

I was a fan. It was one of the shows that was always on, always good. It's still always on, though my re-runs of choice have changed, so I don't tend to watch it.

Was too young to ship, but I used to like Margaret and Hawkeye - probably one of my first will they-won't they ships looking back.

I very much agree with you on Frank - I didn't hate the character as much as I should have either, although I was kind of fond of Charles as well.

Hawkeye - I preferred the earlier version, and feel he was kind of smoothed out too much, probably due to what you say about Alan Alda.

I sort of saw it in two parts, so I knew the end before the beginning, so didn't have many huge feelings either way.

I like most of the actors still (those who are still with us). I think Klinger was part of my formative liking men in drag thing as well.
karaokegal
Jun. 19th, 2016 04:58 am (UTC)
I think the links are fixed.

I probably shipped them on some level too, but I still had the resentment toward what the writers did to Frank to "redeem" Hot Lips.

I really want to finish this stupid meme, but I'm having a harder and harder time remembering how I perceived the older shows the first time around...at least beyond the first ones I wrote about that I had the more visceral relationships with.
joanne_c
Jun. 20th, 2016 05:12 am (UTC)
Yep, they are!

I think it was bad writing but then TV has no shortage of that, even in good shows. Not a diss, just how it is.

I think it can be hard, yeah. I guess there wouldn't be 19 newer ones you could do that you haven't already?

Also did you hear about Anton Yelchin? So sad.

Edited at 2016-06-20 05:13 am (UTC)
( 9 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

Rose
karaokegal
karaokegal

Latest Month

August 2017
S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Jamison Wieser