karaokegal (karaokegal) wrote,
karaokegal
karaokegal

  • Location:
  • Mood:

Who babble for The Hungry Earth

Just a bit of babble ahead.



I feel like we're about to head back into RTD's tendency toward big message episodes instead of fun ones. So far we've got some anti-drilling plus WAR IS BAD looming as the big themes.


Some nice bits here, especially allowing Rory to be awesome, and letting the Doctor be vry creepy alien, which was kind of missing from Tennant's Doctor.

I'm liking all the supporting characters, including the kid, and really don't mind it being an Amy-lite episode. LOVE Nasreen.

UH---Doctor, are you sure that everybody hiding out in a church is such a great idea? (I'm having Father's Day flashbacks myself.)

Chibnall's work here is least serviceable. He's really a puzzle. Some great TW (KKBB and Day 1) and some of the worst, including Cyberwoman and Adrift. BLECH!!! However he also wrote for Life On Mars, which earns him major brownie points. Also-42...he seems to have a recurring mining issues.

This wasn't nearly as fun as the past few eps and feels like filler. Just like (surprise) 42.
Tags: doctor who, journal, torchwood
Subscribe

  • Shetland!

    Jimmy/Duncan I need to start reading fic immediately. I need to *not* start considering Yuletide possibilities. Done is done. (We started Hinterlands…

  • Yuletide 2019

    Probably my last one, unless my work schedule and priorities change drastically. Thanks to all my writers, recipients, betas and hand-holders.…

  • Self-care and self-destruction

    Private yoga lesson with my favorite teacher-CHECK! Massage that I've been promising myself since hubby broke his arm-CHECK And now I'm set up at a…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 9 comments